Note: I wrote this review before playing the Visual Novel that it was biased off of
_____________________________________________________________________
***This is a spoiler free review***
Never in my life would I expect myself to say, “Man I wish this anime
would of stayed a typical stale harem story.” Well brace yourselves
because
Maji de Watashi ni Koi Shinasai!! biggest flaw is its attempt to combine harem, ecchi, and terrorist plot elements into a twelve episode season.
Story: 2/10
So the first two episodes of this anime actually lead the show on a
promising path. Initially I thought this anime was going to be a school
life/slice of life/harem type anime which even though as been done to
death is sometimes good to go back to and just enjoy. The first episode
showcased a class war while the second puts the characters on an odd job
to find a lost dog. The flow between the characters seemed to be done
very well but as soon as the third episode hits, they introduce a
terrorist plot to the anime that completely…kills it (in a bad way). The
anime tries to become super serious and add backstory to some of the
characters but unfortunately it just fails. It’s a shame because I was
really looking forward to a nice laid back anime.
Animation: 8.2/10
The animation on the other hand came out pretty good. I was lucky
enough to get to watch this season on my friends BD copy in 1920x1080
resolution and I have to say…ecchi. There are a lot of scenes where
there are some suggested sexual content but nothing that pushes the bar
too much. In terms of overall quality of the scenes, it is kind of a
mixed bag. The scenes where not a lot is going on is filled with some
impressive visuals, however I noticed that the action scenes are filled
with some artifacting (which shouldn't happen on a BD copy of the
anime...) and some loss of quality. Overall it’s a great looking anime
so props for that.
Sound: 6/10
The soundtrack leaves much to be desired but the voice acting is
recorded fairly well and also has pretty good actors to back them up.
Each character has a unique and well done vocal track. The only issue
that really bothers me about the sound in this anime is that the overall
soundtrack is just bland and uninspiring.
Characters: 6.5/10
In terms of my overall enjoyment with the characters of this anime I
have to say that I did love some of the characters. The ones that stood
out to me the most was the sex crazy Shina, the main character Naoe, and
the shy Mayuzumi who uses a keychain to communicate with others
(thinking that it is a god). Everyone else however comes off as generic
and, “Oh I remember someone like her from like five other anime.”
Generic doesn’t always mean “bad” but for this anime it just seems like
they didn’t try to push the character development enough to get these
said generic characters out of the typical cookie cutter descriptions.
Overall: 5.7/10
Overall I really, really, really wanted to enjoy this anime because
the initial episode really gave me hope and had me hooked. It turns out
however that a weird and unneeded plot device can and will run an anime
with subpar character development and average sound. It’s hard to
recommend this to anyone but hey if you need to kill some time at least
it’s not horrible.
_________________________________________________________________________
Its a decent anime...but go play the VN instead :D